Market analysts are questioning the Federal Reserve’s push for additional interest-rate increases, arguing that policymakers may be basing their decisions on economic figures that no longer reflect current conditions. The recent decline in gasoline, crude oil and other commodity prices suggests inflation could already be losing momentum.
Critics say the Fed risks making a policy mistake by concentrating on delayed indicators such as the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Producer Price Index (PPI). These reports measure price changes from the previous month, meaning they may not capture the latest shifts in commodity and energy markets.
In contrast, real-time market indicators, including gasoline futures, refining margins and prices at gas stations, are showing signs of easing inflation.
“Inflation is a lagging indicator. It tells you what you paid last month. The crack spread is a leading indicator. It tells you what you’ll pay next month. One says inflation is too high. The other says it’s already falling. The Fed is listening to the first one. It’s about to hike into falling prices at the pump,” said Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Zurich-based asset manager Arvy, regulated by Swiss financial watchdog FINMA.
The possibility of further monetary tightening has also become a concern for Bitcoin investors, as higher borrowing costs generally reduce appetite for riskier investments. Recent Fed meeting minutes and public comments from policymakers have reinforced expectations of additional rate increases.
Minutes from the October meeting, released Wednesday, showed that nearly all participants considered further increases in the federal funds rate potentially necessary over the coming months. Officials argued that additional tightening could help return inflation to the central bank’s 2% target, based on their baseline economic forecasts.
Two policymakers went further, suggesting that a December increase of more than 25 basis points could be justified if upcoming inflation figures came in above expectations. A basis point represents 0.01 percentage point, making 25 basis points equal to a quarter-point increase.
Fed Governor Christopher Waller said Wednesday that he supported a 50-basis-point rate increase in December, which would be twice the standard adjustment. Governor Michael Barr also indicated that higher rates could be appropriate, while San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly favored a more gradual approach.
Higher interest rates typically make loans and other forms of borrowing more expensive, potentially reducing liquidity and weighing on investment demand. This environment can create additional pressure on Bitcoin and other risk assets.
However, analysts argue that Fed officials are placing too much emphasis on October’s CPI and PPI reports. Although those figures showed price increases spreading across various goods and services, they do not fully account for the recent downturn in energy and commodity markets.
Energy prices have been a major contributor to inflation since the Iran war began in early March.
Refining margins point to further gasoline price declines
One indicator challenging the Fed’s inflation outlook is the crack spread, which measures how much money oil refiners earn by converting crude oil into products such as gasoline and diesel. It represents the difference between the cost of crude oil and the market value of the refined fuels.
The commonly used 3-2-1 crack spread estimates the revenue generated when three barrels of crude oil are processed into two barrels of gasoline and one barrel of diesel.
When this margin contracts, it generally indicates that refined fuel prices are declining faster than crude oil. Such movements can eventually translate into lower prices for consumers at gas stations.
Data shared by James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at wealth management firm Wellington Altus, showed that the 3-2-1 crack spread had plunged 36% over six weeks. It declined from $65.56 per barrel to $41.90 as of Wednesday.
Thorne believes the sharp contraction reflects growing weakness in fuel markets, following a period when attractive refining margins encouraged producers to increase output.
He explained that higher refinery production has contributed to an oversupply of gasoline and diesel, pushing their prices down more rapidly than crude oil.
Thorne also highlighted wholesale RBOB gasoline futures, which have declined approximately 20%, while retail gasoline prices have reached around $3.78 per gallon.
RBOB futures track wholesale gasoline prices traded by refiners and market participants on the NYMEX. The contracts dropped 11.1% and 6.1% over the previous two completed weeks, representing a combined decline of approximately 16.5%.
Prices have fallen another 4.4% so far this week, taking the three-week decline close to 20%. CoinDesk’s analysis of TradingView data indicates that this is the largest decline over such a period since March 2020.
Retail prices are also moving lower. AAA reported that the average U.S. price of regular gasoline reached $3.75 per gallon on Thursday, down 12.8% from a month earlier and 4.9% over the past week. Despite the recent decline, prices remain around 22% above their level a year ago.
Thorne expects further reductions at the pump because retail fuel prices usually take several weeks to reflect changes in wholesale markets.
He estimated that a 10-cent decline in gasoline prices could reduce headline CPI by approximately nine basis points. According to his assessment, November could deliver a negative headline inflation reading, while the March year-over-year comparison would no longer include the earlier surge in energy prices associated with the war.
He argued that the current situation reflects excess supply rather than a collapse in consumer demand. In his view, falling energy costs are already helping reduce inflation, potentially limiting the need for additional monetary tightening.
Broad commodity market weakness adds to cooling inflation signals
The decline in energy prices is part of a wider downturn across commodity markets.
Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, reviewed the performance of commodity-related exchange-traded funds through Wednesday’s closing bell. These funds primarily track futures contracts, so their performance does not always match movements in spot commodity prices.
Gasoline-focused ETF UGA has fallen 20.9% since the beginning of November. The United States crude oil fund (USO) has declined 19.4%, while the Brent crude ETF (BNO) has lost 18.7%.
Other commodity investments have also experienced significant losses. Broad commodity funds are down approximately 12%, while the copper ETF (CPER) has dropped 12.5%.
Agricultural markets have weakened as well. Wheat’s ETF (WEAT) has declined 4.6%, while the corn fund (CORN) is down 2.7%. Gold’s ETF (GLD) has also recorded a 4.1% loss.
Natural gas remains an exception, gaining 16.9% during November.
The widespread weakness in commodity markets has led some investors to question why the Federal Reserve continues to signal a preference for tighter monetary policy.
James Lavish, co-managing partner of Bitcoin Opportunity Fund, suggested that the Fed’s increasingly aggressive messaging could be intended to pressure financial markets before policymakers eventually decide to stop raising rates.
He questioned the prospect of a 50-basis-point increase in December, particularly as energy-related inflation pressures appear to be easing.
Meanwhile, interest-rate futures continue to reflect expectations of a 25-basis-point increase in December and another in January, with an additional increase potentially arriving by April.
































